| Anti-Virus Comparative August 2005 Copyright (c) by Andreas Clementi (www.av-comparatives.org) - Tested on Windows XP Professional SP2 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Company | H+BEDV Datentechnik | Alwil Software | GriSoft | Softwin | Doctor Web | Frisk Software | Trend Micro | Kaspersky Labs | McAfee | ESET | Symantec | Sophos | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Product | AntiVir Workstation | Avast! Prof. | AVG Professional | BitDefender Prof.+ | Dr. Web | F-Prot Anti-Virus | Internet Security | KAV Personal Pro | McAfee VirusScan | NOD32 Anti-Virus | Norton Anti-Virus | Sophos Anti-Virus | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Program version | 6.31.00.03 | 4.6.691 | 7.0.338 | 8.0.200 | 4.32b | 3.16c | 12.1.1034 | 5.0.372 | 10.0.21 | 2.51.8 | 11.0.11.4 | 5.0.5 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Engine / signature version | 6.31.1.0 / 6.31.1.62 | 0531-4 | 267.10.1/64 | 7.02560 | 4.32b | 3.16.6 | 7.510.1002 / 2.761.00 | N/A | 4.4.00 / 4551 | 1.1187 | 70805q | 2.30.12 / 3.96 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Signature date (mm/dd/yyyy) | 08/05/2005 | 08/05/2005 | 08/04/2005 | 08/05/2005 | 08/05/2005 | 08/05/2005 | 08/04/2005 | 08/05/2005 | 08/05/2005 | 08/05/2005 | 08/05/2005 | 08/05/2005 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Number of virus records | 202.710 | unknown | unknown | 198.395 | 82.894 | 191.534 | unknown | 142.285 | 141.156 | unknown | 70.431 | 108.226 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| On-demand detection rate of dialers (*) | excellent | high | excellent | excellent | high | not present | not present | excellent | excellent | excellent | excellent | high | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Certification level reached in this test | ADVANCED | STANDARD | STANDARD | ADVANCED+ | STANDARD | ADVANCED | STANDARD | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED+ | STANDARD | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| On-demand detection of virus/malware | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| DOS viruses/malware | 240.449 | 226.936 | 94,38% | 231.502 | 96,28% | 218.854 | 91,02% | 235.678 | 98,02% | 230.341 | 95,80% | 239.904 | 99,77% | 228.305 | 94,95% | 240.367 | 99,97% | 240.429 | 99,99% | 238.266 | 99,09% | 240.243 | 99,91% | 233.765 | 97,22% | |||||||||||||||||
| Windows viruses | 19.393 | 14.830 | 76,47% | 17.710 | 91,32% | 15.794 | 81,44% | 18.602 | 95,92% | 17.441 | 89,93% | 18.218 | 93,94% | 16.841 | 86,84% | 19.376 | 99,91% | 19.329 | 99,67% | 19.264 | 99,33% | 19.364 | 99,85% | 17.478 | 90,13% | |||||||||||||||||
| Macro viruses | 37.206 | 37.159 | 99,87% | 36.680 | 98,59% | 37.150 | 99,85% | 36.813 | 98,94% | 37.172 | 99,91% | 37.206 | 100% | 37.088 | 99,68% | 37.206 | 100% | 37.206 | 100% | 37.190 | 99,96% | 37.186 | 99,95% | 37.143 | 99,83% | |||||||||||||||||
| Script viruses/malware | 6.802 | 4.260 | 62,63% | 4.226 | 62,13% | 2.298 | 33,78% | 6.318 | 92,88% | 5.456 | 80,21% | 6.505 | 95,63% | 4.823 | 70,91% | 6.772 | 99,56% | 6.682 | 98,24% | 6.562 | 96,47% | 6.630 | 97,47% | 4.657 | 68,47% | |||||||||||||||||
| Worms | 19.331 | 18.304 | 94,69% | 16.446 | 85,08% | 17.920 | 92,70% | 18.820 | 97,36% | 17.820 | 92,18% | 17.840 | 92,29% | 17.670 | 91,41% | 19.315 | 99,92% | 19.283 | 99,75% | 19.147 | 99,05% | 19.233 | 99,49% | 15.796 | 81,71% | |||||||||||||||||
| Backdoors | 55.011 | 54.040 | 98,23% | 45.311 | 82,37% | 53.107 | 96,54% | 53.533 | 97,31% | 49.836 | 90,59% | 49.235 | 89,50% | 47.642 | 86,60% | 54.963 | 99,91% | 52.935 | 96,23% | 53.837 | 97,87% | 54.403 | 98,89% | 42.053 | 76,44% | |||||||||||||||||
| Trojans | 36.234 | 33.945 | 93,68% | 26.583 | 73,36% | 21.365 | 58,96% | 34.045 | 93,96% | 26.945 | 74,36% | 29.731 | 82,05% | 27.266 | 75,25% | 36.154 | 99,78% | 31.377 | 86,60% | 33.580 | 92,68% | 35.124 | 96,94% | 20.158 | 55,63% | |||||||||||||||||
| other malware | 5.011 | 3.977 | 79,37% | 4.066 | 81,14% | 1.431 | 28,56% | 4.798 | 95,75% | 3.311 | 66,07% | 3.995 | 79,72% | 3.749 | 74,82% | 4.995 | 99,68% | 4.648 | 92,76% | 4.780 | 95,39% | 4.826 | 96,31% | 2.981 | 59,49% | |||||||||||||||||
| OtherOS viruses/malware | 1.734 | 888 | 51,21% | 1.008 | 58,13% | 334 | 19,26% | 1.344 | 77,51% | 904 | 52,13% | 1.185 | 68,34% | 937 | 54,04% | 1.529 | 88,18% | 1.675 | 96,60% | 1.423 | 82,06% | 1.674 | 96,54% | 1.309 | 75,49% | |||||||||||||||||
| TOTAL | 421.171 | 394.339 | 93,63% | 383.532 | 91,06% | 368.253 | 87,44% | 409.951 | 97,34% | 389.226 | 92,42% | 403.819 | 95,88% | 384.321 | 91,25% | 420.677 | 99,88% | 413.564 | 98,19% | 414.049 | 98,31% | 418.683 | 99,41% | 375.340 | 89,12% | |||||||||||||||||
| Total without DOS & OtherOS | 178.988 | 166.515 | 93,0% | 151.022 | 84,4% | 149.065 | 83,3% | 172.929 | 96,6% | 157.981 | 88,3% | 162.730 | 90,9% | 155.079 | 86,6% | 178.781 | 99,9% | 171.460 | 95,8% | 174.360 | 97,4% | 176.766 | 98,8% | 140.266 | 78,4% | |||||||||||||||||
| (*) = not present (0-5%), low (6-40%), mediocre (41-70%), high (71-95%), excellent (96-100%) | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| It is forbidden to provide the tables or results in full or in parts on other sites! Please just refer a link to www.av-comparatives.org | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| If you have questions about the tests and/or the results, please ask us directly in our forum (www.av-comparatives.org/forum). | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Before asking, please read carefully also the test reports and all the other documents on our website. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Please do not put to much attention to the precentages, as little differences in the percentages do not say much. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| It is better you rely on the levels (advanced+, advanced, standard) reached in this test (see http://www.av-comparatives.org/seiten/overview.html) | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Products belonging to a category can be considered as good as the other products in the same category (regarding the on-demand detection rate). | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| The main source of new samples are submissions from AV companies, end users, honeypots, etc. We do not replicate every sample. Read details in the FAQ. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| We do not guarantee a perfect test-set, but the remaining number of "garbage files" contained is so small, that it does not affect the rankings and levels reached by the anti-virus scanners. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||