Retrospective / ProActive - Test November 2005 Copyright (c) by Andreas Clementi (www.av-comparatives.org) - Tested on Windows XP Professional SP2                                    
   
     
  Company     H+BEDV Datentechnik   Alwil Software   GriSoft     Softwin     Doctor Web     Frisk Software   Trend Micro     Kaspersky Labs   McAfee     ESET     Symantec    
  Product     AntiVir Workstation   Avast! Prof.   AVG Professional   BitDefender Prof.+   Dr. Web     F-Prot Anti-Virus   Internet Security   KAV Personal Pro   McAfee VirusScan   NOD32 Anti-Virus   Norton Anti-Virus  
  Program version     6.31.00.03     4.6.691     7.0.338     8.0.200     4.32b     3.16c     12.1.1034     5.0.372     10.0.21     2.51.8     11.0.11.4    
  Engine / signature version     6.31.1.0 / 6.31.1.62   0531-4     267.10.1/64     7.02560     4.32b     3.16.6     7.510.1002 / 2.761.00   N/A     4.4.00 / 4551    1.1187      70805q    
  Signature date (mm/dd/yyyy)     08/05/2005     08/05/2005     08/04/2005     08/05/2005     08/05/2005     08/05/2005     08/04/2005     08/05/2005     08/05/2005     08/05/2005     08/05/2005    
  Number of virus records           202.710     unknown      unknown            198.395             82.894          191.534     unknown           142.285           141.156     unknown     70.431    
                                             
  Certification level reached in this test:    STANDARD     STANDARD          ADVANCED+    ADVANCED     STANDARD     STANDARD     ADVANCED     ADVANCED    ADVANCED+    STANDARD   
  ProActive detection of ITW-samples*                                                          
  In-The-Wild samples   8                   1 13%    0  0%    0  0%                   2 25%                   1 13%    0  0%      0  0%    0  0%                   1 13%   4 50%   0 0%  
  ProActive detection of "NEW" zoo-samples**  
  DOS viruses   10                    1 10%                    1 10%                    3 30%                    4 40%    0  0%                   3 30%    0  0%    0  0%                    1 10%                    3 30%                    3 30%  
  Windows viruses   34                    1 3%                    1 3%                    3 9%                  10 29%                    8 24%                 10 29%    0  0%                    4 12%                  11 32%                  13 38%                    9 26%  
  Macro viruses                8                    8 100%                    1 13%                    1 13%                    6 75%                    5 63%                   7 88%    0  0%    0  0%                    5 63%                    4 50%                    1 13%  
  Script viruses              44                    6 14%                    1 2%    0  0%                  17 39%                  21 48%    0  0%    0  0%                    6 14%                  16 36%    0  0%                    4 9%  
  Worms            590                107 18%                  63 11%                  29 5%                244 41%                111 19%               124 21%                  62 11%                  95 16%                189 32%                382 65%                  78 13%  
  Backdoors         3.921                649 17%                888 23%                260 7%             2.429 62%             1.277 33%               878 22%             1.346 34%             2.111 54%             1.712 44%             2.835 72%                531 14%  
  Trojans         3.179                356 11%                180 6%                  48 2%             1.116 35%                514 16%               318 10%                  69 2%                291 9%                770 24%             1.628 51%                208 7%  
  other malware              66                    4 6%                    5 8%                    3 5%                  14 21%                    5 8%                   3 5%                    1 2%                    1 2%                  26 39%                    8 12%                    2 3%  
  OtherOS malware              28                    2 7%    0  0%    0  0%                    1 4%    0  0%    0  0%    0  0%    0  0%                    4 14%    0  0%                    1 4%  
  TOTAL   7.880             1.134 14%             1.140 14%                347 4%             3.841 49%             1.941 25%            1.343 17%             1.478 19%             2.508 32%             2.734 35%             4.873 62%                837 11%  
         
 
It is forbidden to provide the tables or results in full or in parts on other sites! Please just refer a link to www.av-comparatives.org
If you have questions about the tests and/or the results, please ask us directly in our forum (www.av-comparatives.org/forum).
Before asking, please read carefully also the test reports and all the other documents on our website.
* = new ITW-samples appeared during the 5. August and the 1. October - please read the comments in the report !!!
** = new zoo-samples received during the 5. August and the 5. November that were new to all tested scanners
NOTE: All products detects with updated signatures/programs 100% of the used ITW-samples.
This test shows the pure proactive detection capability that the scanners had 3 months ago with best possible settings. Detection failures in a retrospective test are not up for discussion.
To determine how good a scanner is in detecting zoo-samples on-demand in general with updated signatures, have a look on our February and August tests.
In order to have the highest available protection and proactive detection capabilities, keep your Anti-Virus always up-to-date.
The used programs/updates are 3 month old due the design of the retrospective test. This is a way to determine the on-demand proactive detection capability.
Please do not put to much attention to the percentages. Please rely on the reached certification levels.
As the retrospective test-sets vary each time, you should not compare directly the percentages with different (older) tests.