Anti-Virus Comparative February 2006 Copyright (c) by Andreas Clementi (www.av-comparatives.org) - Tested on Windows XP Professional SP2                                                                    
                         
     
  Company     AVIRA (aka H+B EDV)   G DATA Security   Alwil Software   GriSoft     Softwin     Doctor Web     Frisk Software   F-Secure     Kaspersky Labs   McAfee     ESET     Norman ASA     Symantec     Panda Software   AEC     VirusBlokAda  
  Product     AntiVir PE Premium   AntiVirusKit (AVK)   Avast! Professional   AVG Professional   BitDefender Prof.+   Dr. Web     F-Prot Anti-Virus   F-Secure Anti-Virus   KAV Personal Pro   McAfee VirusScan   NOD32 Anti-Virus   NormanVirusControl   Norton Anti-Virus   Panda Anti-Virus   TrustPort AV WS   VBA32 Workstation  
  Program version     7.00.00.21     16.0.5     4.6.763     7.1.375     9.0 (Build 9)     4.33.0.09293     3.16f     6.12.90     5.0.391     10.0.21     2.51.20     5.81     12.1.0.20     10.01.02     1.5.0.752     3.10.5    
  Engine / signature version     6.33.0.36 / 6.33.0.210   16.5355 / 16.2619   0606-1     267.15.2/252     7.05596     4.33.0.10250     3.16.13     6.11.11450     N/A     5.0.00 / 4690      1.1395      5.83.11     80206u     N/A     N/A     N/A    
  Number of virus records              307.383     unknown     unknown      unknown             269.149            102.156            232.823     unknown            175.260            175.087     unknown     unknown     72.044            110.254     unknown            163.237    
  On-demand detection of dialers (*)      excellent       excellent      high      excellent       excellent       high       not present       not present       excellent       excellent      excellent      low      excellent     excellent     excellent      high     
                                                                           
  Certification level reached in this test   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED   STANDARD   ADVANCED   STANDARD   STANDARD   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED+   STANDARD   ADVANCED+   STANDARD   ADVANCED+        
  On-demand detection of virus/malware  
  DOS viruses/malware   231.088          229.494 99,31%          230.960 99,94%          226.849 98,17%          210.583 91,13%          227.290 98,36%          221.422 95,82%          230.561 99,77%          231.028 99,97%          231.029 99,97%          231.073 99,99%          230.399 99,70%           222.625 96,34%          230.847 99,90%          223.429 96,69%         230.148 99,59%          197.847 85,62%  
  Windows viruses   20.546            18.798 91,49%            20.328 98,94%            19.102 92,97%            17.015 82,81%            19.152 93,22%            18.576 90,41%            18.667 90,85%            20.513 99,84%            20.513 99,84%            20.501 99,78%            20.468 99,62%             16.285 79,26%            20.526 99,90%            17.736 86,32%            20.051 97,59%            13.414 65,29%  
  Macro viruses       37.181            37.143 99,90%            37.181 100%            36.644 98,56%            37.137 99,88%            36.791 98,95%            37.144 99,90%            37.174 99,98%            37.181 100%            37.181 100%            37.180 100%            37.164 99,95%             37.147 99,91%            37.178 99,99%            37.065 99,69%            37.177 99,99%            27.481 73,91%  
  Script viruses/malware         7.449              5.712 76,68%              7.430 99,74%              6.652 89,30%              3.127 41,98%              6.891 92,51%              5.709 76,64%              6.802 91,31%              7.405 99,41%              7.386 99,15%              7.201 96,67%              7.269 97,58%               2.591 34,78%              7.227 97,02%              5.813 78,04%              6.962 93,46%              2.379 31,94%  
  Worms       23.398            22.573 96,47%            23.376 99,91%            22.352 95,53%            22.188 94,83%            22.797 97,43%            22.077 94,35%            21.101 90,18%            23.296 99,56%            23.294 99,56%            23.335 99,73%            23.288 99,53%             18.100 77,36%            23.192 99,12%            20.623 88,14%            23.022 98,39%            17.754 75,88%  
  Backdoors       78.092            77.181 98,83%            78.027 99,92%            71.076 91,02%            76.116 97,47%            73.934 94,68%            73.032 93,52%            65.656 84,08%            77.906 99,76%            77.906 99,76%            75.786 97,05%            76.946 98,53%             74.192 95,01%            76.723 98,25%            68.817 88,12%            76.815 98,36%            68.207 87,34%  
  Trojans       69.008            66.695 96,65%            68.992 99,98%            55.447 80,35%            62.364 90,37%            60.650 87,89%            55.188 79,97%            49.653 71,95%            68.488 99,25%            68.494 99,26%            63.569 92,12%            66.445 96,29%             57.845 83,82%            65.618 95,09%            53.364 77,33%            66.485 96,34%            54.675 79,23%  
  other malware         5.912              4.880 82,54%              5.874 99,36%              4.713 79,72%              2.129 36,01%              5.159 87,26%              3.578 60,52%              4.179 70,69%              5.803 98,16%              5.788 97,90%              5.468 92,49%              5.100 86,27%               1.228 20,77%              5.449 92,17%              4.020 68,00%              5.211 88,14%              2.749 46,50%  
  OtherOS viruses/malware         2.085              1.402 67,24%              2.072 99,38%              1.458 69,93%                 376 18,03%              1.447 69,40%                 977 46,86%              1.232 59,09%              2.065 99,04%              2.065 99,04%              1.894 90,84%              1.843 88,39%                  508 24,36%              1.942 93,14%              1.383 66,33%              1.488 71,37%                 233 11,18%  
  TOTAL   243.671          234.384 96,19%          243.280 99,84%          217.444 89,24%          220.452 90,47%          226.821 93,08%          216.281 88,76%          204.464 83,91%          242.657 99,58%          242.627 99,57%          234.934 96,41%          238.523 97,89%           207.896 85,32%          237.855 97,61%          208.821 85,70%          237.211 97,35%          186.892 76,70%  
  Total with DOS viruses/malware   474.759          463.878 97,71%          474.240 99,89%          444.293 93,58%          431.035 90,79%          454.111 95,65%          437.703 92,19%          435.025 91,63%          473.685 99,77%          473.656 99,77%          466.007 98,16%          468.922 98,77%           430.521 90,68%          468.702 98,72%          432.250 91,05%          467.359 98,44%          384.739 81,04%  
         
  On-demand detection of polymorphic viruses (**)   90,7%   99,9%   26,7%   10,0%   79,5%   93,3%   90,0%   99,4%   99,4%   84,0%   94,3%   36,0%   100%   37,0%   84,9%   15,1%  
         
 
  (*) = not present (0-5%), low (6-40%), mediocre (41-70%), high (71-95%), excellent (96-100%)
  (**) = detection of some selected high polymorphic viruses; please read the report for details; percentages were rounded
  NOTE: Starting from 2006, the reduced DOS category is counted separatly.
  ALL PRODUCTS WERE UPDATED ON MONDAY, THE 6TH FEBRUARY 2006.
 
It is forbidden to provide the tables or results in full or in parts on other sites! Please just refer a link to www.av-comparatives.org
If you have questions about the tests and/or the results, please ask us directly in our forum (www.av-comparatives.org/forum).
Before asking, please read carefully also the test reports and all the other documents on our website.
Please do not put to much attention to the precentages, as little differences in the percentages do not say much.
It is better you rely on the levels (advanced+, advanced, standard) reached in this test (see http://www.av-comparatives.org/seiten/overview.html)
Products belonging to a category can be considered as good as the other products in the same category (regarding the on-demand detection rate).