| Anti-Virus Comparative February 2006 Copyright (c) by Andreas Clementi (www.av-comparatives.org) - Tested on Windows XP Professional SP2 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Company | AVIRA (aka H+B EDV) | G DATA Security | Alwil Software | GriSoft | Softwin | Doctor Web | Frisk Software | F-Secure | Kaspersky Labs | McAfee | ESET | Norman ASA | Symantec | Panda Software | AEC | VirusBlokAda | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Product | AntiVir PE Premium | AntiVirusKit (AVK) | Avast! Professional | AVG Professional | BitDefender Prof.+ | Dr. Web | F-Prot Anti-Virus | F-Secure Anti-Virus | KAV Personal Pro | McAfee VirusScan | NOD32 Anti-Virus | NormanVirusControl | Norton Anti-Virus | Panda Anti-Virus | TrustPort AV WS | VBA32 Workstation | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Program version | 7.00.00.21 | 16.0.5 | 4.6.763 | 7.1.375 | 9.0 (Build 9) | 4.33.0.09293 | 3.16f | 6.12.90 | 5.0.391 | 10.0.21 | 2.51.20 | 5.81 | 12.1.0.20 | 10.01.02 | 1.5.0.752 | 3.10.5 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Engine / signature version | 6.33.0.36 / 6.33.0.210 | 16.5355 / 16.2619 | 0606-1 | 267.15.2/252 | 7.05596 | 4.33.0.10250 | 3.16.13 | 6.11.11450 | N/A | 5.0.00 / 4690 | 1.1395 | 5.83.11 | 80206u | N/A | N/A | N/A | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Number of virus records | 307.383 | unknown | unknown | unknown | 269.149 | 102.156 | 232.823 | unknown | 175.260 | 175.087 | unknown | unknown | 72.044 | 110.254 | unknown | 163.237 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| On-demand detection of dialers (*) | excellent | excellent | high | excellent | excellent | high | not present | not present | excellent | excellent | excellent | low | excellent | excellent | excellent | high | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Certification level reached in this test | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED | STANDARD | ADVANCED | STANDARD | STANDARD | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED+ | STANDARD | ADVANCED+ | STANDARD | ADVANCED+ | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| On-demand detection of virus/malware | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| DOS viruses/malware | 231.088 | 229.494 | 99,31% | 230.960 | 99,94% | 226.849 | 98,17% | 210.583 | 91,13% | 227.290 | 98,36% | 221.422 | 95,82% | 230.561 | 99,77% | 231.028 | 99,97% | 231.029 | 99,97% | 231.073 | 99,99% | 230.399 | 99,70% | 222.625 | 96,34% | 230.847 | 99,90% | 223.429 | 96,69% | 230.148 | 99,59% | 197.847 | 85,62% | |||||||||||||||||||
| Windows viruses | 20.546 | 18.798 | 91,49% | 20.328 | 98,94% | 19.102 | 92,97% | 17.015 | 82,81% | 19.152 | 93,22% | 18.576 | 90,41% | 18.667 | 90,85% | 20.513 | 99,84% | 20.513 | 99,84% | 20.501 | 99,78% | 20.468 | 99,62% | 16.285 | 79,26% | 20.526 | 99,90% | 17.736 | 86,32% | 20.051 | 97,59% | 13.414 | 65,29% | |||||||||||||||||||
| Macro viruses | 37.181 | 37.143 | 99,90% | 37.181 | 100% | 36.644 | 98,56% | 37.137 | 99,88% | 36.791 | 98,95% | 37.144 | 99,90% | 37.174 | 99,98% | 37.181 | 100% | 37.181 | 100% | 37.180 | 100% | 37.164 | 99,95% | 37.147 | 99,91% | 37.178 | 99,99% | 37.065 | 99,69% | 37.177 | 99,99% | 27.481 | 73,91% | |||||||||||||||||||
| Script viruses/malware | 7.449 | 5.712 | 76,68% | 7.430 | 99,74% | 6.652 | 89,30% | 3.127 | 41,98% | 6.891 | 92,51% | 5.709 | 76,64% | 6.802 | 91,31% | 7.405 | 99,41% | 7.386 | 99,15% | 7.201 | 96,67% | 7.269 | 97,58% | 2.591 | 34,78% | 7.227 | 97,02% | 5.813 | 78,04% | 6.962 | 93,46% | 2.379 | 31,94% | |||||||||||||||||||
| Worms | 23.398 | 22.573 | 96,47% | 23.376 | 99,91% | 22.352 | 95,53% | 22.188 | 94,83% | 22.797 | 97,43% | 22.077 | 94,35% | 21.101 | 90,18% | 23.296 | 99,56% | 23.294 | 99,56% | 23.335 | 99,73% | 23.288 | 99,53% | 18.100 | 77,36% | 23.192 | 99,12% | 20.623 | 88,14% | 23.022 | 98,39% | 17.754 | 75,88% | |||||||||||||||||||
| Backdoors | 78.092 | 77.181 | 98,83% | 78.027 | 99,92% | 71.076 | 91,02% | 76.116 | 97,47% | 73.934 | 94,68% | 73.032 | 93,52% | 65.656 | 84,08% | 77.906 | 99,76% | 77.906 | 99,76% | 75.786 | 97,05% | 76.946 | 98,53% | 74.192 | 95,01% | 76.723 | 98,25% | 68.817 | 88,12% | 76.815 | 98,36% | 68.207 | 87,34% | |||||||||||||||||||
| Trojans | 69.008 | 66.695 | 96,65% | 68.992 | 99,98% | 55.447 | 80,35% | 62.364 | 90,37% | 60.650 | 87,89% | 55.188 | 79,97% | 49.653 | 71,95% | 68.488 | 99,25% | 68.494 | 99,26% | 63.569 | 92,12% | 66.445 | 96,29% | 57.845 | 83,82% | 65.618 | 95,09% | 53.364 | 77,33% | 66.485 | 96,34% | 54.675 | 79,23% | |||||||||||||||||||
| other malware | 5.912 | 4.880 | 82,54% | 5.874 | 99,36% | 4.713 | 79,72% | 2.129 | 36,01% | 5.159 | 87,26% | 3.578 | 60,52% | 4.179 | 70,69% | 5.803 | 98,16% | 5.788 | 97,90% | 5.468 | 92,49% | 5.100 | 86,27% | 1.228 | 20,77% | 5.449 | 92,17% | 4.020 | 68,00% | 5.211 | 88,14% | 2.749 | 46,50% | |||||||||||||||||||
| OtherOS viruses/malware | 2.085 | 1.402 | 67,24% | 2.072 | 99,38% | 1.458 | 69,93% | 376 | 18,03% | 1.447 | 69,40% | 977 | 46,86% | 1.232 | 59,09% | 2.065 | 99,04% | 2.065 | 99,04% | 1.894 | 90,84% | 1.843 | 88,39% | 508 | 24,36% | 1.942 | 93,14% | 1.383 | 66,33% | 1.488 | 71,37% | 233 | 11,18% | |||||||||||||||||||
| TOTAL | 243.671 | 234.384 | 96,19% | 243.280 | 99,84% | 217.444 | 89,24% | 220.452 | 90,47% | 226.821 | 93,08% | 216.281 | 88,76% | 204.464 | 83,91% | 242.657 | 99,58% | 242.627 | 99,57% | 234.934 | 96,41% | 238.523 | 97,89% | 207.896 | 85,32% | 237.855 | 97,61% | 208.821 | 85,70% | 237.211 | 97,35% | 186.892 | 76,70% | |||||||||||||||||||
| Total with DOS viruses/malware | 474.759 | 463.878 | 97,71% | 474.240 | 99,89% | 444.293 | 93,58% | 431.035 | 90,79% | 454.111 | 95,65% | 437.703 | 92,19% | 435.025 | 91,63% | 473.685 | 99,77% | 473.656 | 99,77% | 466.007 | 98,16% | 468.922 | 98,77% | 430.521 | 90,68% | 468.702 | 98,72% | 432.250 | 91,05% | 467.359 | 98,44% | 384.739 | 81,04% | |||||||||||||||||||
| On-demand detection of polymorphic viruses (**) | 90,7% | 99,9% | 26,7% | 10,0% | 79,5% | 93,3% | 90,0% | 99,4% | 99,4% | 84,0% | 94,3% | 36,0% | 100% | 37,0% | 84,9% | 15,1% | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| (*) = not present (0-5%), low (6-40%), mediocre (41-70%), high (71-95%), excellent (96-100%) | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| (**) = detection of some selected high polymorphic viruses; please read the report for details; percentages were rounded | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| NOTE: Starting from 2006, the reduced DOS category is counted separatly. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ALL PRODUCTS WERE UPDATED ON MONDAY, THE 6TH FEBRUARY 2006. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| It is forbidden to provide the tables or results in full or in parts on other sites! Please just refer a link to www.av-comparatives.org | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| If you have questions about the tests and/or the results, please ask us directly in our forum (www.av-comparatives.org/forum). | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Before asking, please read carefully also the test reports and all the other documents on our website. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Please do not put to much attention to the precentages, as little differences in the percentages do not say much. | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| It is better you rely on the levels (advanced+, advanced, standard) reached in this test (see http://www.av-comparatives.org/seiten/overview.html) | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Products belonging to a category can be considered as good as the other products in the same category (regarding the on-demand detection rate). | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||