Retrospective / ProActive - Test May 2006 Copyright (c) by Andreas Clementi (www.av-comparatives.org) - Tested on Windows XP Professional SP2                                                                
 
     
  Company     AVIRA     G DATA Security   Alwil Software   GriSoft     Softwin     Doctor Web     Frisk Software   F-Secure     Kaspersky Labs   McAfee     ESET     Norman ASA     Symantec     Panda Software   AEC     VirusBlokAda  
  Product     AntiVir PE Premium   AntiVirusKit (AVK)   Avast! Professional   AVG Professional   BitDefender Prof.+   Dr. Web     F-Prot Anti-Virus   F-Secure Anti-Virus   KAV Personal Pro   McAfee VirusScan   NOD32 Anti-Virus   NormanVirusControl   Norton Anti-Virus   Panda Anti-Virus   TrustPort AV WS   VBA32 Workstation  
  Program version     7.00.00.21     16.0.5     4.6.763     7.1.375     9.0 (Build 9)     4.33.0.09293     3.16f     6.12.90     5.0.391     10.0.21     2.51.20     5.81     12.1.0.20     10.01.02     1.5.0.752     3.10.5    
  Engine / signature version     6.33.0.36 / 6.33.0.210   16.5355 / 16.2619   0606-1     267.15.2/252     7.05596     4.33.0.10250     3.16.13     6.11.11450     N/A     5.0.00 / 4690      1.1395      5.83.11     80206u     N/A     N/A     N/A    
  Number of virus records            307.383     unknown     unknown      unknown             269.149            102.156            232.823     unknown            175.260            175.087     unknown     unknown     72.044            110.254     unknown            163.237    
                                                                 
  Certification level reached*      ADVANCED      ADVANCED+      ADVANCED       STANDARD      ADVANCED+      ADVANCED       STANDARD       ADVANCED       ADVANCED       ADVANCED      ADVANCED+    ADVANCED       STANDARD       ADVANCED      ADVANCED+      ADVANCED     
                                                                     
  Number of false positives*        many       few       few      few      few       many       few       few       few      very few      few       few      none      few       few      many    
  On-demand scanning speed*        fast       slow       average       average       average       average       average       slow       average       average       fast       average       average       fast       slow      slow    
  ProActive detection of "NEW" samples**  
  DOS malware   35                     1 3%                   16 46%                     7 20%                   16 46%                   16 46%                     5 14%                   16 46%                     7 20%                     7 20%                     9 26%                   16 46%                      5 14%                   14 40%                     4 11%                   16 46%                   25 71%  
  Windows viruses   39                     7 18%                     8 21%                     8 21%                     3 8%                     8 21%                     7 18%    0  0%                     2 5%                     2 5%                     8 21%                   19 49%                      2 5%                     6 15%                     6 15%                     8 21%                     6 15%  
  Script malware            217                   62 29%                   36 17%                   51 24%                 137 63%                   24 11%                   41 19%                     1 0%                   18 8%                   26 12%                   35 16%                   31 14%                    58 27%                   37 17%                   17 8%                   24 11%                   23 11%  
  Worms            502                 239 48%                 306 61%                   51 10%                   25 5%                 302 60%                 249 50%                 120 24%                   35 7%                   33 7%                 111 22%                 409 81%                  201 40%                 109 22%                   92 18%                 324 65%                 160 32%  
  Backdoors         3.836              2.400 63%              2.277 59%              1.260 33%                 153 4%              1.973 51%              1.971 51%                 599 16%              1.680 44%              1.685 44%              1.477 39%              2.946 77%               1.316 34%                 772 20%              1.412 37%              2.130 56%              2.692 70%  
  Trojans         3.638              1.726 47%              1.425 39%                 296 8%                   38 1%              1.375 38%              1.428 39%                 188 5%                   74 2%                   76 2%                 725 20%              1.382 38%                  583 16%                 242 7%                 832 23%              1.461 40%              1.780 49%  
  other malware            356                 263 74%                 271 76%                 217 61%                 229 64%                 268 75%                 199 56%                 192 54%                 232 65%                 232 65%                 279 78%                 223 63%                  234 66%                 237 67%                 232 65%                 269 76%                 249 70%  
  OtherOS malware            122                   29 24%                     8 7%                     8 7%    0  0%                     8 7%                     1 1%    0  0%                     8 7%                     8 7%                   19 16%                     8 7%    0  0%                   14 11%    0  0%                     8 7%    0  0%  
  TOTAL   8.745              4.727 54%              4.347 50%              1.898 22%                 601 7%              3.974 45%              3.901 45%              1.116 13%              2.056 24%              2.069 24%              2.663 30%              5.034 58%               2.399 27%              1.431 16%              2.595 30%              4.240 48%              4.935 56%  
         
 
It is forbidden to provide the tables or results in full or in parts on other sites! Please just refer a link to www.av-comparatives.org
Please read carefully also the test reports and the other documents on our website to understand how to interpret the results.
* = read the report for details ( ! )
** = new malware samples received during the 6th February and the 6th May that were new to all tested scanners
This test shows the pure proactive ON-DEMAND detection capability that the scanners had 3 months ago with best possible detection settings. Detection failures in a retrospective test are not up for discussion.
To determine how good a scanner is in detecting zoo-samples on-demand in general with updated signatures, have a look on our February and August tests.
In order to have the highest available protection and proactive detection capabilities, keep your Anti-Virus always up-to-date.
Please rely on the reached certification levels and NOT on the percentages.