| Anti-Virus Comparative August 2006 Copyright (c) by Andreas Clementi (www.av-comparatives.org) - Tested on Windows XP Professional SP2 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Company | AVIRA | G DATA Security | Alwil Software | GriSoft | Softwin | Doctor Web | Frisk Software | F-Secure | Kaspersky Labs | McAfee | ESET | Norman ASA | Symantec | AEC | VirusBlokAda | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Product | AntiVir PE Premium | AntiVirusKit (AVK) | Avast! Professional | AVG Professional | BitDefender Prof.+ | Dr. Web | F-Prot Anti-Virus | F-Secure Anti-Virus | Kaspersky AV | McAfee VirusScan | NOD32 Anti-Virus | NormanVirusControl | Norton Anti-Virus | TrustPort AV WS | VBA32 Workstation | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Program version | 7.01.01.02 | 16.0.7 | 4.7.869 | 7.1.405 | 9.5 | 4.33.4.07270 | 3.16f | 6.12.90 | 6.0.0.303 | 11.0.209 | 2.51.26 | 5.81 | 12.2.0.13 | 2.0.0.843 | 3.11.0 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Engine / signature version | 6.35.01.60 | 16.8976 / 16.5352 | 0631-3 | 268.10.7 / 411 | 7.08453 | 4.33.2.06080 | 3.16.13 | 6.11.11450 | N/A | 5100.0194 / 4823 | 1.1695 | 5.90.23 | 80807 | N/A | N/A | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Number of virus records | 477.718 | unknown | unknown | unknown | 458.019 | 134.337 | 313.508 | unknown | 213.193 | 203.043 | unknown | unknown | 72.713 | unknown | unknown | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| On-demand detection of over 205000 dialers (*) | excellent | excellent | excellent | excellent | excellent | high | not present | not present | excellent | excellent | excellent | mediocre | excellent | excellent | high | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| On-demand detection of polymorphic viruses (**) | 10 of 10 | 8 of 10 | 2 of 10 | 1 of 10 | 5 of 10 | 7 of 10 | 4 of 10 | 6 of 10 | 6 of 10 | 5 of 10 | 8 of 10 | 1 of 10 | 10 of 10 | 5 of 10 | 1 of 10 | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Certification level reached in this test | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED | STANDARD | ADVANCED | STANDARD | STANDARD | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED+ | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| On-demand detection of virus/malware | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| DOS viruses/malware | 230.456 | 230.337 | 99,95% | 230.340 | 99,95% | 226.213 | 98,16% | 210.520 | 91,35% | 226.718 | 98,38% | 220.770 | 95,80% | 229.879 | 99,75% | 230.428 | 99,99% | 230.427 | 99,99% | 230.445 | ~100% | 229.786 | 99,71% | 222.065 | 96,36% | 230.250 | 99,91% | 229.514 | 99,59% | 197.982 | 85,91% | ||||||||||||||||||
| Windows viruses | 21.985 | 21.608 | 98,29% | 21.964 | 99,90% | 20.558 | 93,51% | 18.600 | 84,60% | 20.660 | 93,97% | 19.984 | 90,90% | 20.918 | 95,15% | 21.942 | 99,80% | 21.942 | 99,80% | 21.878 | 99,51% | 21.743 | 98,90% | 18.052 | 82,11% | 21.954 | 99,86% | 21.517 | 97,87% | 14.855 | 67,57% | ||||||||||||||||||
| Macro viruses | 38.295 | 38.282 | 99,97% | 38.294 | ~100% | 37.738 | 98,55% | 38.245 | 99,87% | 38.201 | 99,75% | 38.253 | 99,89% | 38.290 | 99,99% | 38.294 | ~100% | 38.294 | ~100% | 38.295 | 100% | 38.292 | 99,99% | 38.274 | 99,95% | 38.292 | 99,99% | 38.288 | 99,98% | 33.525 | 87,54% | ||||||||||||||||||
| Script viruses/malware | 7.865 | 7.722 | 98,18% | 7.811 | 99,31% | 6.691 | 85,07% | 3.330 | 42,34% | 7.425 | 94,41% | 5.859 | 74,49% | 7.329 | 93,18% | 7.764 | 98,72% | 7.733 | 98,32% | 7.438 | 94,57% | 7.709 | 98,02% | 6.910 | 87,86% | 7.704 | 97,95% | 7.666 | 97,47% | 4.351 | 55,32% | ||||||||||||||||||
| Worms | 28.573 | 28.504 | 99,76% | 28.553 | 99,93% | 27.283 | 95,49% | 27.172 | 95,10% | 28.185 | 98,64% | 27.080 | 94,77% | 26.338 | 92,18% | 28.455 | 99,59% | 28.455 | 99,59% | 28.221 | 98,77% | 28.487 | 99,70% | 26.777 | 93,71% | 28.427 | 99,49% | 28.422 | 99,47% | 25.374 | 88,80% | ||||||||||||||||||
| Backdoors | 104.816 | 104.610 | 99,80% | 104.446 | 99,65% | 98.655 | 94,12% | 100.812 | 96,18% | 102.116 | 97,42% | 98.180 | 93,67% | 91.834 | 87,61% | 103.878 | 99,11% | 103.877 | 99,10% | 98.086 | 93,58% | 103.546 | 98,79% | 102.253 | 97,55% | 103.613 | 98,85% | 104.061 | 99,28% | 90.613 | 86,45% | ||||||||||||||||||
| Trojans | 110.648 | 110.023 | 99,44% | 110.168 | 99,57% | 97.759 | 88,35% | 102.537 | 92,67% | 101.288 | 91,54% | 93.592 | 84,59% | 88.008 | 79,54% | 109.028 | 98,54% | 109.030 | 98,54% | 94.847 | 85,72% | 108.324 | 97,90% | 104.582 | 94,52% | 106.854 | 96,57% | 108.864 | 98,39% | 86.478 | 78,16% | ||||||||||||||||||
| other malware | 6.801 | 6.689 | 98,35% | 6.732 | 98,99% | 5.389 | 79,24% | 3.417 | 50,24% | 6.305 | 92,71% | 4.231 | 62,21% | 5.975 | 87,85% | 6.682 | 98,25% | 6.659 | 97,91% | 6.024 | 88,58% | 6.627 | 97,44% | 4.863 | 71,50% | 6.285 | 92,41% | 6.414 | 94,31% | 4.093 | 60,18% | ||||||||||||||||||
| OtherOS viruses/malware | 2.356 | 2.321 | 98,51% | 2.352 | 99,83% | 1.585 | 67,28% | 530 | 22,50% | 1.772 | 75,21% | 1.092 | 46,35% | 1.450 | 61,54% | 2.323 | 98,60% | 2.323 | 98,60% | 2.131 | 90,45% | 2.159 | 91,64% | 589 | 25,00% | 2.217 | 94,10% | 1.887 | 80,09% | 236 | 10,02% | ||||||||||||||||||
| TOTAL | 321.339 | 319.759 | 99,51% | 320.320 | 99,68% | 295.658 | 92,01% | 294.643 | 91,69% | 305.952 | 95,21% | 288.271 | 89,71% | 280.142 | 87,18% | 318.366 | 99,07% | 318.313 | 99,06% | 296.920 | 92,40% | 316.887 | 98,61% | 302.300 | 94,08% | 315.346 | 98,13% | 317.119 | 98,69% | 259.525 | 80,76% | ||||||||||||||||||
| Total with DOS viruses/malware | 551.795 | 550.096 | 99,69% | 550.660 | 99,79% | 521.871 | 94,58% | 505.163 | 91,55% | 532.670 | 96,53% | 509.041 | 92,25% | 510.021 | 92,43% | 548.794 | 99,46% | 548.740 | 99,45% | 527.365 | 95,57% | 546.673 | 99,07% | 524.365 | 95,03% | 545.596 | 98,88% | 546.633 | 99,06% | 457.507 | 82,91% | ||||||||||||||||||
| (*) = not present (0-5%), low (6-40%), mediocre (41-70%), high (71-95%), excellent (96-100%). | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| (**) = reliable detection of 10 high polymorphic viruses; you MUST read the report for details! | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| NOTE: Starting from 2006, the DOS category is counted separatly. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ALL PRODUCTS WERE UPDATED ON MONDAY, THE 7th AUGUST 2006. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| It is forbidden to provide the tables or results in full or in parts on other sites! Please just refer a link to www.av-comparatives.org | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| If you have questions about the tests and/or the results, please ask us directly in our forum (www.av-comparatives.org/forum). | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Before asking, please read carefully also the test reports and all the other documents on our website. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Please do not put to much attention to the precentages, as little differences in the percentages do not say much. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| It is better you rely on the levels (advanced+, advanced, standard) reached in this test (see http://www.av-comparatives.org/seiten/overview.html) | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Products belonging to a category can be considered as good as the other products in the same category (regarding the on-demand detection rate). | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||