Anti-Virus Comparative August 2006 Copyright (c) by Andreas Clementi (www.av-comparatives.org) - Tested on Windows XP Professional SP2                                                                
                     
     
  Company     AVIRA     G DATA Security   Alwil Software   GriSoft     Softwin     Doctor Web     Frisk Software   F-Secure     Kaspersky Labs   McAfee     ESET     Norman ASA     Symantec     AEC     VirusBlokAda  
  Product     AntiVir PE Premium   AntiVirusKit (AVK)   Avast! Professional   AVG Professional   BitDefender Prof.+   Dr. Web     F-Prot Anti-Virus   F-Secure Anti-Virus   Kaspersky AV   McAfee VirusScan   NOD32 Anti-Virus   NormanVirusControl   Norton Anti-Virus   TrustPort AV WS   VBA32 Workstation  
  Program version     7.01.01.02     16.0.7     4.7.869     7.1.405     9.5     4.33.4.07270     3.16f     6.12.90     6.0.0.303     11.0.209     2.51.26     5.81     12.2.0.13     2.0.0.843     3.11.0    
  Engine / signature version     6.35.01.60     16.8976 / 16.5352   0631-3     268.10.7 / 411   7.08453     4.33.2.06080     3.16.13     6.11.11450     N/A     5100.0194 / 4823    1.1695      5.90.23     80807     N/A     N/A    
  Number of virus records            477.718      unknown       unknown      unknown            458.019            134.337            313.508     unknown            213.193            203.043     unknown     unknown     72.713     unknown     unknown    
                                                             
  On-demand detection of over 205000 dialers (*)    excellent       excellent       excellent       excellent       excellent       high       not present       not present       excellent       excellent      excellent      mediocre      excellent     excellent      high     
  On-demand detection of polymorphic viruses (**)     10 of 10     8 of 10     2 of 10     1 of 10     5 of 10     7 of 10     4 of 10     6 of 10     6 of 10     5 of 10     8 of 10     1 of 10     10 of 10     5 of 10     1 of 10  
                                                                         
  Certification level reached in this test   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED   STANDARD   ADVANCED   STANDARD   STANDARD   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED+        
  On-demand detection of virus/malware  
  DOS viruses/malware   230.456          230.337 99,95%          230.340 99,95%          226.213 98,16%          210.520 91,35%          226.718 98,38%          220.770 95,80%          229.879 99,75%          230.428 99,99%          230.427 99,99%          230.445 ~100%          229.786 99,71%           222.065 96,36%          230.250 99,91%         229.514 99,59%          197.982 85,91%  
  Windows viruses   21.985            21.608 98,29%            21.964 99,90%            20.558 93,51%            18.600 84,60%            20.660 93,97%            19.984 90,90%            20.918 95,15%            21.942 99,80%            21.942 99,80%            21.878 99,51%            21.743 98,90%             18.052 82,11%            21.954 99,86%            21.517 97,87%            14.855 67,57%  
  Macro viruses       38.295            38.282 99,97%            38.294 ~100%            37.738 98,55%            38.245 99,87%            38.201 99,75%            38.253 99,89%            38.290 99,99%            38.294 ~100%            38.294 ~100%            38.295 100%            38.292 99,99%             38.274 99,95%            38.292 99,99%            38.288 99,98%            33.525 87,54%  
  Script viruses/malware         7.865              7.722 98,18%              7.811 99,31%              6.691 85,07%              3.330 42,34%              7.425 94,41%              5.859 74,49%              7.329 93,18%              7.764 98,72%              7.733 98,32%              7.438 94,57%              7.709 98,02%               6.910 87,86%              7.704 97,95%              7.666 97,47%              4.351 55,32%  
  Worms       28.573            28.504 99,76%            28.553 99,93%            27.283 95,49%            27.172 95,10%            28.185 98,64%            27.080 94,77%            26.338 92,18%            28.455 99,59%            28.455 99,59%            28.221 98,77%            28.487 99,70%             26.777 93,71%            28.427 99,49%            28.422 99,47%            25.374 88,80%  
  Backdoors     104.816          104.610 99,80%          104.446 99,65%            98.655 94,12%          100.812 96,18%          102.116 97,42%            98.180 93,67%            91.834 87,61%          103.878 99,11%          103.877 99,10%            98.086 93,58%          103.546 98,79%           102.253 97,55%          103.613 98,85%          104.061 99,28%            90.613 86,45%  
  Trojans     110.648          110.023 99,44%          110.168 99,57%            97.759 88,35%          102.537 92,67%          101.288 91,54%            93.592 84,59%            88.008 79,54%          109.028 98,54%          109.030 98,54%            94.847 85,72%          108.324 97,90%           104.582 94,52%          106.854 96,57%          108.864 98,39%            86.478 78,16%  
  other malware         6.801              6.689 98,35%              6.732 98,99%              5.389 79,24%              3.417 50,24%              6.305 92,71%              4.231 62,21%              5.975 87,85%              6.682 98,25%              6.659 97,91%              6.024 88,58%              6.627 97,44%               4.863 71,50%              6.285 92,41%              6.414 94,31%              4.093 60,18%  
  OtherOS viruses/malware         2.356              2.321 98,51%              2.352 99,83%              1.585 67,28%                 530 22,50%              1.772 75,21%              1.092 46,35%              1.450 61,54%              2.323 98,60%              2.323 98,60%              2.131 90,45%              2.159 91,64%                  589 25,00%              2.217 94,10%              1.887 80,09%                 236 10,02%  
  TOTAL   321.339          319.759 99,51%          320.320 99,68%          295.658 92,01%          294.643 91,69%          305.952 95,21%          288.271 89,71%          280.142 87,18%          318.366 99,07%          318.313 99,06%          296.920 92,40%          316.887 98,61%           302.300 94,08%          315.346 98,13%          317.119 98,69%          259.525 80,76%  
  Total with DOS viruses/malware   551.795          550.096 99,69%          550.660 99,79%          521.871 94,58%          505.163 91,55%          532.670 96,53%          509.041 92,25%          510.021 92,43%          548.794 99,46%          548.740 99,45%          527.365 95,57%          546.673 99,07%           524.365 95,03%          545.596 98,88%          546.633 99,06%          457.507 82,91%  
         
 
  (*) = not present (0-5%), low (6-40%), mediocre (41-70%), high (71-95%), excellent (96-100%).
  (**) = reliable detection of 10 high polymorphic viruses; you MUST read the report for details!
  NOTE: Starting from 2006, the DOS category is counted separatly.
  ALL PRODUCTS WERE UPDATED ON MONDAY, THE 7th AUGUST 2006.
 
It is forbidden to provide the tables or results in full or in parts on other sites! Please just refer a link to www.av-comparatives.org
If you have questions about the tests and/or the results, please ask us directly in our forum (www.av-comparatives.org/forum).
Before asking, please read carefully also the test reports and all the other documents on our website.
Please do not put to much attention to the precentages, as little differences in the percentages do not say much.
It is better you rely on the levels (advanced+, advanced, standard) reached in this test (see http://www.av-comparatives.org/seiten/overview.html)
Products belonging to a category can be considered as good as the other products in the same category (regarding the on-demand detection rate).