| Retrospective / ProActive - Test May 2008 Copyright (c) by AV-Comparatives (www.av-comparatives.org) - Tested on Windows XP Professional SP2 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| NOTE: Due some changes in the test, this time the results show only how the products scored at a specific (quite short) time and may due that not necessarly apply in general. Please read the report for details. Next time the test results will be again more meaningful, by including a larger quantity of samples and 2 different time-frames. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Company | AVIRA | G DATA Security | Alwil Software | AVG Technologies | BitDefender | MicroWorld | F-Secure | Kaspersky Labs | McAfee | Microsoft | ESET | Norman ASA | Symantec | Sophos | AEC | VirusBlokAda | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Product | AntiVir PE Premium | AntiVirusKit (AVK) | Avast! Professional | AVG Anti-Malware | BitDefender AV | eScan Anti-Virus | F-Secure Anti-Virus | Kaspersky AV | McAfee VirusScan+ | Microsoft OneCare | NOD32 Anti-Virus | Norman ISS AV+AS | Norton Anti-Virus | Sophos Anti-Virus | TrustPort AV WS | VBA32 Anti-Virus | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Program version | 7.06.00.308 | 18.0.7227.533 | 4.7.1098 | 7.5.516 | 11.0.15 | 9.0.768.1 | 8.00.101 | 7.0.1.321a | 12.0.176 | 2.0.2500.22 | 3.0.621.0 | 7.0 | 15.0.0.58 | 7.0.7 | 1.4.2.428 | 3.12.6.0 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Engine / signature version | 7.06.00.62 / 7.00.02.90 | 18.2654 / 18.123 | 080203-0 | 269.19.19 / 1258 | 7.17325 | N/A | 7.30.13161 | N/A | 5200.2160 / 5222 | 1.3204 / 1.27.6270.0 | 2847 | 5.91.10 | 100204 / 78215 | 2.70.1 / 4.26E+132 | 2.6.0.1237 | unknown | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Number of virus records | 1.092.160 | unknown | unknown | unknown | 978.896 | unknown | unknown | 574.209 | 371.817 | 723.778 | unknown | 1.310.735 | 73.845 | 345.615 | unknown | unknown | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Certification level reached* | ADVANCED+ | ADVANCED | STANDARD | ADVANCED | STANDARD | STANDARD | ADVANCED | ADVANCED | ADVANCED+ | STANDARD | STANDARD | STANDARD | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Number of false positives* | few | few | many | few | many | very few | very few | very few | none | few | few | many | very few | (very) many | (very) many | many | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| On-demand scanning speed* | fast | slow | average | average | average | slow | slow | slow | average | average | average | average | fast | average | slow | slow | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ProActive detection of "NEW" samples** | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Windows viruses | 190 | 171 | 90% | 151 | 79% | 149 | 78% | 145 | 76% | 166 | 87% | 110 | 58% | 110 | 58% | 144 | 76% | 148 | 78% | 125 | 66% | 45 | 24% | 135 | 71% | 12 | 6% | 164 | 86% | 173 | 91% | 134 | 71% | ||||||||||||||||||||
| Script malware | 287 | 95 | 33% | 17 | 6% | 14 | 5% | 66 | 23% | 33 | 11% | 3 | 1% | 9 | 3% | 5 | 2% | 23 | 8% | 36 | 13% | 9 | 3% | 15 | 5% | 63 | 22% | 59 | 21% | 80 | 28% | 1 | 0% | ||||||||||||||||||||
| Worms | 586 | 418 | 71% | 159 | 27% | 154 | 26% | 241 | 41% | 294 | 50% | 50 | 9% | 54 | 9% | 108 | 18% | 214 | 37% | 140 | 24% | 425 | 73% | 148 | 25% | 141 | 24% | 422 | 72% | 351 | 60% | 93 | 16% | ||||||||||||||||||||
| Backdoors | 4.055 | 3.193 | 79% | 1.702 | 42% | 1.682 | 41% | 1.592 | 39% | 2.022 | 50% | 165 | 4% | 165 | 4% | 782 | 19% | 1.676 | 41% | 1.182 | 29% | 2.713 | 67% | 1.821 | 45% | 938 | 23% | 3.526 | 87% | 2.935 | 72% | 1.221 | 30% | ||||||||||||||||||||
| Trojans | 6.258 | 4.340 | 69% | 1.274 | 20% | 1.267 | 20% | 1.618 | 26% | 2.556 | 41% | 340 | 5% | 340 | 5% | 1.371 | 22% | 1.574 | 25% | 1.818 | 29% | 3.309 | 53% | 1.954 | 31% | 891 | 14% | 4.323 | 69% | 3.736 | 60% | 1.422 | 23% | ||||||||||||||||||||
| other malware | 133 | 59 | 44% | 13 | 10% | 13 | 10% | 40 | 30% | 41 | 31% | 0 | 0% | 3 | 2% | 3 | 2% | 24 | 18% | 41 | 31% | 19 | 14% | 6 | 5% | 4 | 3% | 44 | 33% | 53 | 40% | 9 | 7% | ||||||||||||||||||||
| TOTAL | 11.509 | 8.276 | 72% | 3.316 | 29% | 3.279 | 28% | 3.702 | 32% | 5.112 | 44% | 668 | 6% | 681 | 6% | 2.413 | 21% | 3.659 | 32% | 3.342 | 29% | 6.520 | 57% | 4.079 | 35% | 2.049 | 18% | 8.538 | 74% | 7.328 | 64% | 2.880 | 25% | ||||||||||||||||||||
| It is forbidden to provide those tables in full or in parts on other sites! Please just refer a link to www.av-comparatives.org | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Please read carefully the test reports and the other documents on our website to understand how to interpret the results. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| * = read the report for details ( ! ) | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| ** = new unique malware appeared between the 5th and the ~12th February 2008 (~1 week); adware, spyware, non-working stuff, etc. are not included | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| This retrospective test shows the proactive on-demand detection capability that the scanners had in February 2008 with highest on-demand detection settings over the 1-week test-set. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| To determine how good a scanner is in detecting malware on-demand in general with updated signatures, have a look on our February and August tests. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Please rely on the reached certification levels (which take false alarms into account) and NOT on the percentages alone. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||