Anti-Virus Comparative August 2008 Copyright (c) by AV-Comparatives e.V. ®  (www.av-comparatives.org) - Tested on Windows XP Professional SP3                                                                
                 
     
  Company     AVIRA     G DATA Security   Alwil Software   AVG Technologies   BitDefender     MicroWorld     ESET     F-Secure     Kaspersky Labs   McAfee     Microsoft     Norman ASA     Symantec     Sophos     Trustport     VirusBlokAda  
  Product     AntiVir Premium   AntiVirusKit (AVK)   avast! Professional   AVG Anti-Virus   BitDefender AV   eScan Anti-Virus   ESET NOD32 Antivirus   F-Secure Anti-Virus   Kaspersky AV   McAfee VirusScan+   Microsoft OneCare   Norman AV+AS   Norton Anti-Virus   Sophos E S&C   TrustPort AV   VBA32 Anti-Virus  
  Program version     8.1.0.362     19.0.0.49     4.8.1229     8.0.156     11.0.17     9.0.824.217     3.0.669.0     9.00.148     8.0.0.454     12.1.110     2.5.2900.03     7.10     16.0.0.125     7.5.1     2.8.0.3006     3.12.8.2    
  Engine / signature version     8.01.01.15/7.00.05.212   N/A     080804-0     270.5.12/1590   N/A     N/A      3325      8.10.14240     N/A     5300.2777 / 5352     1.3807 / 1.41.18.0    5.93.01     100804c / 84315   2.75.4 / 4.31E+305   N/A     N/A    
  Number of virus records         1.533.821      unknown       unknown      unknown         1.414.639     unknown     unknown     unknown         1.045.550            437.316     753.216     1.979.741     2.043.091     447.478     unknown     unknown    
                                                                             
  Certification level reached in this test   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED   ADVANCED   ADVANCED   ADVANCED   ADVANCED+   STANDARD   STANDARD   ADVANCED   ADVANCED+   ADVANCED   ADVANCED+        
                                                                                 
  Number of false positives*     many     many     many     many     many     few     few     few     many     very few     very few     many     few     (very many)*   many     many    
  On-demand scanning speed*     fast     average     average     fast     average     slow     fast     average     fast     fast     average     average     fast     fast     slow     slow    
  On-demand detection of virus/malware:  
  SET A (Aug05 - Sep07)     1.190.818   PASSED     PASSED     PASSED     PASSED     PASSED     PASSED     PASSED     PASSED     PASSED     PASSED     PASSED     PASSED     PASSED     PASSED     PASSED     PASSED    
  SET B (Oct07-Jul08), highest settings:  
  Windows viruses   42.845            42.700 100%            42.789 100%            42.657 100%            41.767 97%            41.344 96%              41.944 98%            42.137 98%            41.994 98%            42.479 99%            41.340 96%            41.129 96%            37.032 86%            42.379 99%            41.355 97%            42.548 99%            35.712 83%  
  Macro viruses             2.571              2.558 99%              2.571 100%              2.571 100%              2.333 91%              2.335 91%                2.551 99%              2.558 99%              2.551 99%              2.551 99%              2.569 100%              2.244 87%              2.348 91%              2.570 100%              2.347 91%              2.373 92%                 990 39%  
  Script malware           10.405            10.029 96%            10.087 97%              9.810 94%              5.931 57%              8.947 86%                9.883 95%              8.893 85%              9.885 95%              9.883 95%              8.023 77%              7.686 74%              5.711 55%              9.074 87%              6.222 60%              7.604 73%              2.789 27%  
  Worms           63.115            62.730 99%            62.783 99%            61.914 98%            59.828 95%            60.595 96%              60.020 95%            59.918 95%            60.054 95%            61.580 98%            54.943 87%            55.789 88%            55.882 89%            62.131 98%            56.398 89%            61.727 98%            52.001 82%  
  Backdoors/Bots         256.749          255.066 99%          254.800 99%          250.335 98%          243.842 95%          229.342 89%            236.835 92%          243.280 95%          237.081 92%          247.518 96%          220.460 86%          214.523 84%          233.846 91%          253.221 99%          231.752 90%          252.833 98%          159.387 62%  
  Trojans         707.230          701.627 99%          700.031 99%          686.885 97%          670.168 95%          659.101 93%            634.302 90%          652.205 92%          635.055 90%          665.540 94%          587.419 83%          596.541 84%          627.162 89%          690.963 98%          640.346 91%          687.453 97%          529.188 75%  
  other malware           13.287            12.784 96%            12.824 97%            12.672 95%            10.153 76%            11.538 87%              12.394 93%            10.472 79%            12.408 93%            12.590 95%            10.243 77%              8.932 67%              8.234 62%            12.489 94%              9.212 69%            11.014 83%              8.180 62%  
  TOTAL   1.096.202       1.087.494 99,2%       1.085.885 99,1%       1.066.844 97,3%       1.034.022 94,3%       1.013.202 92,4%            997.929 91,0%       1.019.463 93,0%          999.028 91,1%       1.042.141 95,1%          924.997 84,4%          926.844 84,6%          970.215 88,5%       1.072.827 97,9%          987.632 90,1%       1.065.552 97,2%          788.247 71,9%  
         
  SET B (Oct07-Jul08), default settings:   ~98,6%   ~99,1%   ~97,3%   ~94,3%   ~92,4%   ~91,0%   ~93,0%   ~91,1%   ~94,4%   ~84,4%   ~84,6%   ~88,5%   ~97,4%   ~90,1%   ~96,9%   ~71,9%  
 
  SET A + B (highest settings)   ~2,3 millions   ~99,6%   ~99,5%   ~98,7%   ~97,3%   ~96,4%   ~95,7%   ~96,6%   ~95,8%   ~97,6%   ~92,5%   ~92,6%   ~94,5%   ~99,0%   ~95,3%   ~98,7%   ~86,5%  
 
 
  * Please read the PDF report for details!
  SET A: in order to get a "PASSED" over SET A, a product must be able to detect - with best possible settings - over 99,5% of this test-set
  SET B: contains malware from last 9 months (~October 2007 to ~July 2008)
  For more results and some guidance to the results, you MUST read the report (and the methodology document)!
  ALL PRODUCTS WERE UPDATED THE 4th AUGUST 2008.
It is forbidden to host the tables or results in full or in parts on other sites! Please just refer a link to www.av-comparatives.org